Wednesday, May 1, 2019

What Does Big Tobacco Really Hate? Hint: It's NOT Tobacco 21 Laws

Clearly, Big Tobacco (including the quisling JUUL Labs who sold out to them) does NOT oppose raising the age limit for tobacco and vaping products to 21.  In fact, they now openly support Tobacco 21 laws, including the latest attempt at the federal level.  It appears to be a cowardly, treacherous Trojan horse to scuttle and pre-empt any laws that they oppose.

But what laws and regulations DO they really, really vehemently oppose these days?  That is the real question here and the answer is:
  • Higher tobacco taxes of any kind, especially on cigarettes but also on other tobacco and vaping products as well.
  • Flavor bans of any kind, whether menthol cigarettes, flavored cigars, or fruity and candy flavors for vape products.
And it is very telling indeed that they oppose those laws so vehemently.  Additionally, as far as age limits go, they also historically have preferred purchase-use-possession (PUP) laws over sales-to-underage (STU) laws, since the former put the onus on young smokers/vapers themselves while the latter put the onus on vendors, and Big Tobacco really HATES the latter even if they pay lip service to it. This has been true with an age limit of 18, and probably will still be their quasi-official stance under an age limit of 21.

Given what we know about what Big Tobacco likes and dislikes, it should be pretty obvious how to combat them effectively.  Don't take the Tobacco 21 bait, Congress!  Keep it 18, and enforce it better by strengthening the Synar Program for retailer compliance checks, ban kid-friendly vape flavors, consider banning menthol cigarettes, cap nicotine levels of vape products down to European and Israeli levels, phase down nicotine levels in cigarettes to a non-addictive level, and raise the taxes on tobacco products (and add a more modest vape tax too).

To sum up Big Tobacco's thought process:
  • Raise cigarette or other tobacco or vape taxes?  HELL NO!
  • Flavor bans?  HELL NO!
  • Restrictions on nicotine content?  HELL NO! 
  • Raise the age limit for tobacco and vaping products to 21?  HELL YEAH!
Remember, anything that Mitch "Awkward Turtle" McConnell (and Big Tobacco) supports has to have some sort of sinister ulterior motives.  Twenty-One Debunked opposes raising the age limit any higher than 18 on principle, regardless of why they want to do it.  But now add in this sinister Big Tobacco dimension and it only becomes all the more repugnant overall.  It truly must be opposed.

1 comment:

  1. I have long noticed there is a sentiment of support for tolitharianism against young people in this country. It makes think that the youth rights movement and this related movement need to be strong in defeating the momentum of tolitharianism. Big Tobacco and JUUL Labs are part of this equation. Those companies support the oppressive smoking and vaping age of 21 while strongly defying effective laws to reduce tobacco and vaping. This movement of oppression against young people deserves to be defeated or the U.S. might will become the most oppressive country in the world. I don't believe North Korea would match it. Any rationale for oppressive laws, rules or attitudes against young people should be thorougly challenged against.

    ReplyDelete